Log In

Reset Password
BERMUDA | RSS PODCAST

Protesters’ joy as mammogram plan dropped

First Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next Last
Juliana Swan had breast cancer diagnosed in 2008 and had three different surgeries, eventually having her breast removed in October of that year. She hung her bra and an artificial breast used to cover the one she had removed on the fence at the Cabinet building as part of the Bras for a Cause protest against proposed changes to mammography screening (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)

Protesters cheered outside the Cabinet Building last night after an unpopular proposal to adopt more stringent insurance coverage for mammography was dropped.

It was an abrupt about-face for Jeanne Atherden, the Minister of Health, who told about 200 women and men that she would not include the policy in the health legislation going up for debate today.

“Part of the development of policy involves creating an understanding around why we institute changes and how they will benefit the people,” Ms Atherden told a largely peaceful crowd.

Saying she intended to do so, the minister assured demonstrators at the “Bras for a Cause” gathering that the breast cancer screening policy would be left off from plans to use United States guidelines.

“This has always been about clinical guidelines and adopting an approach that empowers women to make choices based on their individual needs and in consultation with their physicians to improve their health outcomes and reduce their risks,” she said.

Fielding questions from protesters as she stood on the steps of Cabinet, Ms Atherden conceded that the medical guidelines had not been put to public consultation, but stressed that the move had arisen from talks with physicians and local medical bodies, including the Bermuda Health Council, which endorses the plan.

The issue provoked widespread protest after it emerged from the Health Insurance (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act 2015, tabled by Ms Atherden two weeks ago.

Kim Wilson, Shadow Minister of Health, registered her objections almost instantly.

“This is the power of the people, that’s all I can say — the people spoke, and I commend the Government for listening,” an elated Ms Wilson said after the announcement.

“The fact is that everybody in their own individual ways, by petitions and broadcasts and social media, all came together for a common cause that transcends race, class, politics and even sex, because men can get breast cancer.

“This is a great example of what we can all do when we work together.”

Last night’s demonstration, in which lawns and railings around the Cabinet building were festooned with bras, gained traction quickly this week via social media.

One of the organisers, Kimberley Hines, said her idea started as a playful suggestion just a few nights ago.

“It was a joke, mostly, but the others said, ‘let’s do it’,” Ms Hines said, alongside friends Coral Welles and Rachael Burrows.

Ms Welles told the protest that she had been given 34 bags of bras collected by Secrets Boutique on behalf of people who could not attend.

To applause, she added: “I am not ready to pick up anything from off this yard until it gets passed tomorrow.”

It was a peaceful protest with little heckling of the minister, but Ms Atherden faced some heated questions, with one man accusing her of changing the script without heeding “the needs, wants and demands of the people”.

Another protester interrupted her, asking to know why she was telling people to see their doctors first before being screened

A few people booed as Ms Atherden, flanked by Attorney-General Trevor Moniz; Cole Simons, the One Bermuda Alliance whip; and Patricia Gordon-Pamplin, Minister of Community, Culture and Sport, left the steps of Cabinet.

“I feel personally that they put the cart before the horse — more research needed to be done,” protester Cindy Swan said afterwards.

“They keep saying that we have to go to our doctor but there are a lot of unemployed women in Bermuda that don’t have health insurance.”

In a PLP statement issued later last night, Ms Wilson said there needed to be wider consultation — that the OBA Government “needs to stop trying to force legislation through without consulting the stakeholders and the experts”.

“We are very pleased with this outcome,” she added. “However, it did not have to go this route had the Government acted collaboratively and in the public’s best interest.”

Coral Welles, one of the organisers of Bras for a Cause, dons one of the garments left at the Cabinet building (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)
Sisters Nahjae and Naja look at the bras left by protesters (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)
Joanne Fubler adds to the long line of bras hanging on the fence at the Cabinet building (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)
Kalie Fox-Hine places her hand on the shoulder of her mother, Dilwan Hine, as they look out at the bra-covered lawn of Cabinet (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)
Health Minister Jeanne Atherden announced the proposal will be dropped, flanked by (from left) Government whip Cole Simons, Attorney-General Trevor Moniz and Patricia Gordon-Pamplin, Minister of Community, Culture and Sport (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)
Hundreds of residents of all ages, men and women, attended the protest at Cabinet, leaving bras to show their unhappiness at proposed changes to mammography screenings (Photo by Nicola Muirhead)