Same-sex ruling makes sense

Make text smaller Make text larger

  • Moving with the times: a ruling in the Supreme Court by Chief Justice Ian Kawaley means Bermudians with a same-sex partner can enjoy the same rights afforded to all Bermudians, allowing their partners to reside and seek employment on the Island

    Moving with the times: a ruling in the Supreme Court by Chief Justice Ian Kawaley means Bermudians with a same-sex partner can enjoy the same rights afforded to all Bermudians, allowing their partners to reside and seek employment on the Island
    ((Photograph by The Vacaville Reporter, Rick Roach/AP))


The same-sex debate may have ruffled a few feathers and has been greeted by opponents with grunts of indignation, but in the greater scheme of things, this isnít an issue that needs lengthy discussion.

Equal rights are not malleable.

Freedom of choice must be bracketed with freedom of speech and freedom of expression.

In reality, that isnít always the case but thatís what the world is striving for and Bermuda can play a small part by allowing same-sex partners to live their lives as they are entitled to.

It would be wrong to trivialise the issue but it does seem there has been a lot fuss over a ruling that lifts the Island into the 21st century, will not impact on others and will be accepted by a large majority.

The debate ó and it should never have got this far ó is vaguely interesting and obviously controversial, but it has stirred a pot that was nothing but lukewarm.

The simple fact is that few are worried about how others run their lives; most have enough problems of their own.

They may talk about gay rights in casual conversation, but it rarely escalates into heated argument. And they take little notice of gay marches.

Sports followers are far more interested in the Premier League, the NFL or other major events.

ďIf it doesnít affect me, why would I be bothered to interfere?Ē

But because of its size, Bermuda tends magnify matters that bear little significance elsewhere. Small groups can be more influential than they should be.

Weíre as guilty as the other media of blowing what might be considered minuscule irritations out of proportion. The global powers and many smaller nations focus on crises such as the fight against IS, increased terrorism, migrants pushing their way into Europe, climate control and the economy.

Human rights will always be on the agenda and activists work feverishly to bring to light the atrocities, torture and child abuse, which haunt the world. But rarely is the plight of homosexuals front and centre.

Here there are small pockets in the community who are consumed with outrage over the recent Supreme Court ruling.

At last count, 7,000 residents had reportedly signed a petition condemning those who choose not to engage in a traditional relationship.

That leaves about 53,000 who are totally supportive of that choice and the rest ambivalent.

Indeed, itís those 7,000 who are now ridiculed for their perceived homophobic leanings.

Moving one step forward, gays can now enjoy some of rights afforded all Bermudians, allowing their partners to reside and seek employment on the Island.

Chief Justice Ian Kawaley, who made the ruling, has since made the point that not even legislation is required to put into place that practice.

That does not really impinge on the lives of heterosexuals.

The next step will be to rid the Islandís draconian law that prevents sex-same couples from joining in matrimony. Itís not a case of whether it will happen, but when.

That will, no doubt, further prompt rage from certain church communities who appear to be the main opponents.

Thatís when the Islandís hypocrisy comes to the fore.

They may want to revisit the Ten Commandments (Exodus 20:2-17 NKJV).

Thou shall not murder.

Thou shall not commit adultery.

Thou shall not steal.

Crimes all rife in Bermuda.

If they are so shocked by the gay lifestyle, why not target their anger in the direction of the murderers, the adulterers and the thieves?

Add in the child molesters, of which Bermuda has too many to count.

These are the Islandís pariahs.

Do the critics really believe these crimes are less ungodly than sexual preference?

Over the past decade, entertainers, sportsmen and other public figures have ďcome outĒ, opening the floodgates, emboldening those who feared being ostracised. In the main, it hasnít happened.

Same-sex partners have been allowed to shed the stigma associated with homosexuality.

A few retain the camp manner that can be a source of hilarity but they do so at their own choosing, often for the amusement of others ó this is prevalent in TV comedies and films. The old Carry On films depended on these camp characters to provide the laughter.

The Chief Justiceís ruling comes as a result of a legal action brought by the Bermuda Bred Company against both the Minister of Home Affairs and the Attorney-General.

This group of Bermudians had argued that the Immigration and Protection Act had to be read in conjunction with the Human Rights Act, which does not allow discrimination on the grounds of marital status or sexual orientation.

The groupís argument is as sound as it is sensible.

Canít we now just move on and deal with matters of consequence?

ADRIAN ROBSON

You must be registered or signed-in to post comment or to vote.

Published Dec 15, 2015 at 8:00 am (Updated Dec 15, 2015 at 1:54 am)

Same-sex ruling makes sense

What you
Need to
Know
1. For a smooth experience with our commenting system we recommend that you use Internet Explorer 10 or higher, Firefox or Chrome Browsers. Additionally please clear both your browser's cache and cookies - How do I clear my cache and cookies?
2. Please respect the use of this community forum and its users.
3. Any poster that insults, threatens or verbally abuses another member, uses defamatory language, or deliberately disrupts discussions will be banned.
4. Users who violate the Terms of Service or any commenting rules will be banned.
5. Please stay on topic. "Trolling" to incite emotional responses and disrupt conversations will be deleted.
6. To understand further what is and isn't allowed and the actions we may take, please read our Terms of Service
7. To report breaches of the Terms of Service use the flag icon

  • Take Our Poll

    Today's Obituaries