Passive leads money management
Growth stocks are trouncing value. Small caps are beating large. And more professional managers are beating their benchmarks now than a year earlier.
Those are only some of the details from the latest S&P Indices Versus Active Funds US Scorecard, or Spiva. Twice a year, Standard & Poor’s Indices group releases this deep dive into mutual-fund performance. It analyses funds by capitalisation levels and investment styles to review their performance versus various benchmarks.
A quick caveat: S&P is one of the world’s largest index providers, so it obviously has a dog in this fight. Still, it brings big resources to bear on the simple question of, “How is your portfolio doing this year?” The results for the 12-month period ended June 30 do contain a few surprises, though most of the results are as expected — active management still tends to lag passive, small caps tend to beat large. Sifting through the details can be a worthwhile exercise.
Small versus big: let’s start with the good news first: For investors in US equity markets, returns have been strong. Small-cap stocks (S&P SmallCap 600) did best, gaining 20.5 per cent, followed by large and mid-caps (S&P 500 & MidCap 400) which gained 14.4 and 13.5 per cent, respectively.
Growth versus value: There is more good news if you are in the growth camp: it has been trouncing value for the past decade. Indeed, active managers of growth funds have done extremely well across all market capitalisations. They have beaten their benchmarks by 63.7, 68.5 and 58.0 per cent for large, mid, and small-cap funds, respectively. Whether that is a result of the rise of big dominant tech companies or the post-crisis recovery we can’t say for sure.
Earnings gains are the key: What helps to explain the advantages of growth over value? Gautam Dhingra of High Pointe Capital Management points out that earnings for growth stocks have been strong in this period, gaining 84 per cent, while earnings for value stocks rose 30 per cent. The net result is that since the end of the financial crisis, growth stocks outperformed their value counterparts by 144 per cent net of fees, S&P said.
Time matters: note that these advantages depend upon the time frame. The past month of market volatility hints at conditions that normally lead value to beat growth. The advantages for growth since the 2009 lows owe to the rapid recovery from that bottom and the long rally since then. But when we look at periods that include bull and bear markets, the results are quite different. Consider the time frame from March 2000 to the present — a period that includes both the dot-com implosion and the financial crisis. The performance advantage of growth disappears. Over that 18-year period, value outperformed growth by 157 percentage points.
Active versus passive: some more good news for active fund managers: during that same 12-month period, the overall percentage of active funds that outperformed their benchmarks rose to 42 per cent from 36.6 per cent.
The majority of actively managed equity funds still underperformed their benchmarks. Over the prior five-year period, 76.5 per cent of large-cap, 81.7 per cent of mid-cap and a whopping 92.9 per cent of small-cap managers lagged their respective benchmarks.
The conclusion is as unsurprising as it is inescapable: for the vast majority of investors, inexpensive indices are a superior bet to expensive actively managed funds.
Barry Ritholtz is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist
Dame Jennifer reiterates independence call
Bill to give tourism minister grip on BTA
Not all that glitters is gold
Motorists in Causeway punch-up after crash
Police identify man found dead in home
‘Mr Amazing Man’ defies the odds
Prince of Wales donates art to Masterworks
Police called to reported disturbance
Take Our Poll
- "What are your views on anonymous online commenting (trolling)?"
- Helpful to our democracy and needs to continue
- Hurtful to our democracy and needs to end
- Limits the number of people willing to give public service
- An important tool for political parties
- Total Votes: 4508
- Poll Archive