The people are being failed

  • David Burt, the Premier

    David Burt, the Premier

  • Leah Scott

    Leah Scott


While the Throne Speech is perceived as traditional and ceremonial, the reality is that it is vitally important because it outlines the plans the government of the day intends to pursue, as well as those that it may amend or abandon.

It is the means by which the Government makes the country and businesses aware of its plans, objectives and priorities with respect to its legislative agenda.

Ultimately, the Throne Speech sets out the Government’s commitment to the people of Bermuda and to the businesses that operate in and from within Bermuda. It is a major barometer used by businesses’ annual budget and organisational plans, and it allows them to contemplate the multifaceted aspects of the Government’s proposed policies.

In addition, the Throne Speech usually recognises the important role businesses that operate in Bermuda play in our economic prosperity, as well as discussing the means by which any barriers that impede the island’s competitiveness will be addressed.

David Burt’s reality is this: from July 2017 to date, his government has done nothing to create a better social or business infrastructure, improve our education system, facilitate a competitive business climate, create jobs or any substantial new revenue stream.

In July 2019, the Bermuda Business Confidence Index was published and, at that time, business confidence in Bermuda sat at its lowest level.

Quoting from the report:

“The island’s current economic woes began nearly two years ago. This year, immigration is in the spotlight as a key opportunity for change.

“At the same time, taxation is considered among the top issues facing the island by a notable minority, as is the cost of doing business. In order to turn things around, business leaders are calling on Government for immigration reform, increased foreign investment, and better tax policies. The majority of business leaders now consider the current economic direction to be negative, and this perception is especially elevated among those operating internationally — likely in relation to the addition of Bermuda to the European Union’s tax haven blacklist.”

There are so many things that are going against our people — unemployment and underemployment, lack of affordable housing, imposition of taxes on everything from sugar to rent to land tax. Retail sales continue to decline. Reduced working hours, redundancies, layoffs and reorganisations are on the increase.

Jobs, foreign direct investment, a viable education system and economic growth are the only means by which we can continue to support our families and our communities so that we not only survive, but thrive. All are in short supply under Mr Burt’s government, with no relief in plain sight or even looming on the horizon.

Can the Premier exercise his prerogative to not present a Throne Speech? Absolutely! I mean, after all, he is the Premier. He can, and generally does, do whatever he wants. With a 25-11 majority, why would you take into consideration the needs of the people of the country?

However, Mr Burt must remember that he is a public servant. He was elected by the people to be for the people. As a public servant, he has a duty to facilitate an agenda that addresses the concerns and the questions that are being raised by the people of this country ... you know, the people who elected him to serve them.

So, while the Premier believes that he doesn’t owe a legislative agenda to the Opposition, he absolutely does have an obligation to lay out a plan to the people that addresses:

• How our households, which are either unemployed or underemployed, are going to support their families

• How our seniors, who relied on their homes as investments, are going to be able to pay the increased land tax

• Where our landlords will get tenants to rent their empty apartments because there are just not enough people here

• How restaurateurs and shopkeepers, whose revenues continue a downward spiral, are going to keep their doors open and keep Bermudians employed

• How we establish an education system that produces Bermudians who are able to participate in our economy at the senior level

• How we are going to attract, secure and maintain substantial foreign direct investment in this country that will assist in addressing and supporting our infrastructure and social reformation needs

Not presenting a Throne Speech does not, in any way, eliminate Mr Burt’s accountability to this country. In fact, it actually heightens that he cannot demonstrate any formidable accomplishments his government has achieved since July 2017.

Denying the people the ability to publicly participate in political decision-making is a very selfish move. If the Premier continues to view the people of Bermuda through his consumerism lens, rather than seeing us as a people with rights, then I daresay the day will come when we will see some sort of unrest.

The people of this country marched on the One Bermuda Alliance at every opportunity, and I absolutely support peaceful protest as a tool to have one’s voice heard. So why are we choosing to suffer silently under David Burt’s government?

With all due respect, our rights are our rights, no matter who is in power.

Remember, people will do to us what we let them do. Do not let Mr Burt treat us as a commodity to be manipulated for his own purposes. In 2017, the Progressive Labour Party ran on a manifesto to improve the lives of the people of Bermuda, not to make them poorer and right now, David Burt and his government are failing all of us.

While I may not be able to see where the Government is going, what I clearly see is a country whose people who are weary and worn. A country that has been asking, and continues to ask this government, just what is the plan? A country that wants to know whether David Burt and his PLP government have any sort of plan that will result in future prosperity — and if so, just when will that happen.

We all have a right to know what direction this country is going in and David Burt has an obligation to tell us.

Leah Scott is the Deputy Leader of the One Bermuda Alliance and the Opposition MP for Southampton East Central (Constituency 30)

You must be registered or signed-in to post comment or to vote.

Published Oct 28, 2019 at 8:00 am (Updated Oct 28, 2019 at 7:29 am)

The people are being failed

What you
Need to
Know
1. For a smooth experience with our commenting system we recommend that you use Internet Explorer 10 or higher, Firefox or Chrome Browsers. Additionally please clear both your browser's cache and cookies - How do I clear my cache and cookies?
2. Please respect the use of this community forum and its users.
3. Any poster that insults, threatens or verbally abuses another member, uses defamatory language, or deliberately disrupts discussions will be banned.
4. Users who violate the Terms of Service or any commenting rules will be banned.
5. Please stay on topic. "Trolling" to incite emotional responses and disrupt conversations will be deleted.
6. To understand further what is and isn't allowed and the actions we may take, please read our Terms of Service
7. To report breaches of the Terms of Service use the flag icon

  • Take Our Poll

    Today's Obituaries

    eMoo Posts