Kelly Francis: Poor performance reviews should never come as a surprise
Imagine sitting through your annual performance review and discovering that your manager has been unhappy with your work for the past six months. You met your deadlines, responded to requests and assumed you were doing reasonably well. No one has raised a serious concern. Yet here you are, being told that your performance has fallen below expectations.
I have always found these situations particularly frustrating. Not because employees should be shielded from difficult feedback, but because I struggle to understand how a manager can remain dissatisfied for months and say almost nothing.
At what point does an employee's performance problem become a management problem?
It is that time of year again. Performance appraisal forms are circulating, calendars are filling with review meetings and managers are trying to remember what happened in February. Some will approach the process thoughtfully. Others will regard it as an administrative exercise to complete before the holidays. I suspect employees can tell the difference.
One of the most troubling conversations in performance management begins with an employee saying, “You never told me there was a problem.” Sometimes that is a defensive reaction to feedback they do not welcome. Sometimes it is entirely accurate.
Consider a manager who has repeatedly rewritten an employee’s reports rather than explaining what needs to change. The work gets finished, the client is satisfied and the immediate problem disappears. At year-end, the manager records that the employee's written work is below standard.
From the employee’s perspective, the assessment has come out of nowhere. From the manager’s perspective, the problem has been obvious for months. Both are describing their experience accurately, which is precisely the problem.
The conversations managers avoid
Managers avoid difficult feedback for understandable reasons. They do not want to damage a relationship, discourage someone who is trying hard or create conflict in a small team. Some are unsure how to describe the issue objectively. Others hope the problem will correct itself.
We sometimes devote considerable effort to training managers in performance appraisal systems while overlooking a more basic issue. Some managers are simply unwilling to have uncomfortable conversations.
They will correct the work, complain to another manager, quietly redistribute responsibilities or hope the problem resolves itself. What they don’t do, is sit down with the employee and explain clearly and respectfully what needs to change.
That reluctance has consequences. By the time the annual appraisal arrives, the employee has lost months in which improvement might have been possible.
I have also encountered managers who genuinely believe they have communicated their concerns because they have made passing comments, expressed frustration or corrected someone’s work. They assume the employee understands the message. Often, the employee has interpreted those same interactions quite differently.
A manager’s awareness of a performance problem does not mean the employee is equally aware of it.
Feedback should not be a guessing game
Performance management should be a continuing conversation about expectations, results and development. That does not require an elaborate system. It requires clarity about what good performance looks like and the willingness to discuss the gap when reality falls short.
Specificity matters. “You need to communicate better” tells someone very little. “The last three project updates were sent after the agreed deadline, leaving colleagues unable to prepare” gives them something concrete to address. The purpose of feedback is not to establish that the manager was right. It is to help an employee understand what needs to happen differently, provide an opportunity to improve and recognise progress when it occurs.
There is another group that can be overlooked during appraisal season: the people who consistently deliver. Strong performers are often rewarded with a quick conversation, a positive rating and an assumption that they need little attention.
Yet they may be the employees most eager to discuss stretch assignments, development or the next stage of their careers. An appraisal that simply says “keep up the good work” misses an opportunity. Good performers deserve meaningful conversation, too.
Before the next round of reviews, I encourage managers to ask themselves three questions:
• Have I explained my expectations clearly?
• Have I raised concerns when they arose?
• Would anything in this appraisal genuinely surprise the employee?
A good performance review should bring a year of conversations into focus. It should not be the first meaningful conversation of the year.
Employees have a responsibility to meet reasonable expectations, respond to feedback and take ownership of their performance. Managers have the equally important responsibility to ensure those expectations are understood and concerns are addressed when they arise.
If an employee gets to a December review meeting entirely unaware that their performance has been unacceptable since March, it is time to put some difficult questions to the manager who allowed nine months to pass without a meaningful conversation.
• Kelly Francis is Founder and managing director of Performance Solutions Ltd. She advises boards, business owners and leadership teams on the people decisions that shape organisational performance. Kelly can be reached at 441-232-5270 or kelly_francis@psolutions.bm
