Mind the gap: Berkeley pulling away from CedarBridge in grades race
Bermuda’s public senior schools are continuing to fall short of global averages in international exams, although The Berkeley Institute has shown marked improvement in English IGCSEs in the past two years, an analysis by The Royal Gazette shows.
Results for English and mathematics results for the Cambridge IGCSE exams showed that Berkeley largely outperformed CedarBridge Academy. The results were provided to The Royal Gazette in response to a public access to information request.
The Department of Education provided the majority of IGCSE grades from 2018 to 2025, except for all results for 2020 and 2021, during the Covid-19 pandemic, and most of the results for 2022.
The Gazette calculated the percentage of entries ranging from A* to C, recognised as the baseline pass for progression into higher education.
Overall, the figures showed stronger English and maths results for Berkeley and a widening grades gap between the two schools in both subjects, but persistently weak maths results, especially at CedarBridge.
International averages for 2025 — obtainedvia an earlier Pati request, with the Gazette having been unable to source confirmed information about averages for any other years, were not achieved throughout the period in English or maths.
Science results were mixed, with some significant fluctuations between years.
The results also pointed to dwindling numbers of entries — or number of student grades listed in a given year — throughout the period.
The following shows the percentage of students achieving A* to C in a subject, with number of entries provided in parentheses in the given year.
ENGLISH
Berkeley
2018: 41.8 (153)
2019: 44.3 (151)
2023: 40.9 (132)
2024: 61.2 (162)
2025: 59.5 (131)
CedarBridge
2018: 40.7 (118)
2019: 43.7 (96)
2023: 28.4 (95)
2024: 23.5 (89)
2025: 29.2 (65)
MATHS
Berkeley
2018: 31.4 (181)
2019: 28.8 (184)
2023: 29.5 (159)
2024: 33.9 (162)
2025: 34 (144)
CedarBridge
2018: 22.6 (115)
2019: 7 (113)
2023: 22.4 (116)
2024: 15.3 (98)
2025: 8.1 (74)
The figures prompted condemnation by the Opposition, which repeated calls for Diallo Rabain, the Minister of Education, to resign.
A ministry spokeswoman responded that Mr Rabain would be back in the House of Assembly on Friday to continue a debate on the Education Authority Bill — “the very reform that places durable, arm’s-length governance into statute, and the reform the Opposition claims to support”.
She added: “Calls for resignation from an opposition that has spent more energy on procedural delays than on constructive engagement do not warrant a response.”
The One Bermuda Alliance has attributed consistent underperformance in Bermuda’s public schools to “years of failed leadership”.
Bermuda’s two public senior schools were achieving similar percentages of A* to C grades in English back in 2018, in the region of 41 per cent.
However, by 2025, Berkeley had improved to 59.5 per cent, more than 30 percentage points higher than CedarBridge, where the proportion of students getting A* to C grades had fallen to 29.2 per cent.
That gap was even wider in 2024 when 61.2 per cent of English grades at Berkeley were at the A* to C rate, versus 23.5 per cent at CedarBridge. The 61.2 per cent rate was the highest recorded over the entire period.
However, in 2025, the international average for a percentage of entries between A* to C in English was 84 per cent.
After 2023, Berkeley also saw an increase in the number of grades at B and above.
Maths presented challenges at IGCSE for both schools, although Berkeley showed some improvement.
Berkeley’s results were higher in 2025 than in 2018 — 34 per cent, compared with 31.4 per cent at A* to C respectively.
CedarBridge’s grades, however, showed generally declining figures for maths, from 22.6 per cent in the A* to C bracket in 2018, down to 8.1 per cent in 2025.
In 2019, only 7 per cent of CedarBridge’s grades in maths made the A* to C bracket. There was some recovery in 2023, at 22.4 per cent, and 2024, 15.3 per cent, before the figure slumped again.
In 2025, the international average in maths stood at a 71 per cent A* to C pass rate.
Berkeley’s A* to C rate remained relatively steady over the period. The school ranged from a 28.8 per cent low in 2019 to a high of 34 per cent in 2025.
However, for maths in 2019, 16.8 per cent of Berkeley’s entries came in as ungraded, which means the student did not pass the subject. Figures provided gave that year’s results for Berkeley as AS-level rather than Cambridge IGCSE. The Gazette has asked for clarity.
In the same year, CedarBridge saw 27.4 per cent of its IGCSE maths entries ungraded. That figure leapt to 35.1 per cent in 2025.
Mr Smith told the Gazette: “These results are an indictment of years of failed leadership in education. The problems are not new and neither are the warnings.
“Concerns have been raised repeatedly through parliamentary questions, opinion pieces, public statements and votes of no confidence. Yet we continue to see troubling results without meaningful accountability.
“Minister Rabain has been responsible for education for most of the period covered by these results. He cannot continue announcing reforms without answering for what has happened under his leadership.
“Considering these results and the other poor outcomes recently brought to light, surely every school should have a clear improvement plan.
“What plans are in place? What targets have been set? And what measurable improvements have they delivered?”
Mr Smith said the OBA had fought to strengthen the Education Authority legislation because education needed “genuine independence, transparency and accountability, free from political interference”.
He added: “But the Education Authority cannot become a hiding place for the failures of the current minister.
“Many of the powers being proposed for the authority already exist within the current system. Which of those powers are being used today and what results have they produced?
“During the Education Authority debate, the OBA called for minister Rabain’s resignation, and I repeat that call.
“He has had years to deliver improvement but delivered confusion, anxiety and declining results.
“It is time for him to go.”
The Ministry of Education said 2025 Cambridge Checkpoint and IGCSE results had been available since the education department published them in March.
The 2025 results were posted by the Department of Education after the Gazette requested them via Pati.
The spokeswoman added: “None of this is new, and none of it has been hidden”, but she did not speak to the other years for which responses to questions were requested — 2018 to 2024.
Nor was any comment provided in response to questions about the apparent performance gap between Berkeley and CedarBridge.
She referenced a ministerial statement by Mr Rabain given in July in the House of Assembly following the tabling of a review into primary and middle school performance — not senior — saying accountability rested with the ministry, the department and the minister.
Responding to the OBA’s questions on school improvement, she said: “The minister confirmed that data-driven school improvement plans are in place in every school, aligned with system-wide literacy and numeracy targets.
“Any Honourable Member genuinely focused on improving outcomes for our children would already know this.”
The Gazette contacted the boards of both schools for comment but no responses were received by the time of publication.
