Opposition identifies ‘red flags’ in minister’s response to Belco
An opposition MP has criticised the home affairs minister for taking more than three months to respond to a Belco rate hike rolled out this summer.
In a recent opinion piece, Alexa Lightbourne, the Minister of Home Affairs, asked for justification from Belco for their increased facilities charges for solar energy users.
Dwayne Robinson, the shadow minister, said he welcomed the call for justification but said the article raised “red flags”, suggesting that Ms Lightbourne appeared more concerned about public relations than providing the public with relief.
He said: “The first red flag is the minister’s massively delayed response to the public outcry of Bermudians regarding this new charge introduced by Belco, a whole four months later.
“She is correct in challenging Belco’s justification for the facilities charge placed on solar customers as the people’s primary advocate in this space. The renewable energy transition is key to Bermuda’s energy security and long-term affordability.
“However, the charge came into effect August 1, and the OBA has repeatedly called on the minister to share her plan to safeguard Bermudians and to incentivise solar energy going forward both on and off the floor of the House.”
He said the article also highlighted a “breakdown of communications” between the Government, Belco and the Regulatory Authority.
Mr Robinson said: “The minister should be able to pick up the phone and call the president of Belco and the chief executive of the Regulatory Authority to work on a path forward for Bermudians.
“The average Bermudian may struggle to advocate for themselves to both entities but the minister should have a direct line and if necessary, use the legislated levers, such as ministerial directives, available to her if the people of Bermuda are getting the short end of the stick.”
He questioned if Ms Lightbourne would issue a ministerial directive to the RA to demand less punitive rates for solar users, if she would advocate for proper funding for Consumer Affairs and if reforms to the RA would come before the end of 2026.
Mr Robinson also raised concerns about Ms Lightbourne’s “personal rebuking” of Wayne Caines, the president of Belco, claiming that she had also publicly attacked others who disagreed with her.
He said: “Bermuda must reject this brand of politics as Bermuda needs solution-oriented leaders, to navigate us through these turbulent times.
“Unless the minister plans on starting the national conversation on nationalising Belco, then our current system will persist.
“She will need to improve her working relationship with the RA and Belco, bring forth reforms to the RA to deliver real relief for Bermudians, while avoiding costing the tax payer more legal fees down the line.”
A spokeswoman for the Ministry of Home Affairs denied the claim that Ms Lightbourne waited until November to address the new Belco changes.
The spokeswoman noted “18 months of consistent policy,” which included ministerial direction last May to the Regulatory Authority; the draft National Electricity Sector Policy going to public consultation in April and being finalised in July; the Electricity Amendment Act 2026 passing in June; and the $50,000 balcony solar pilot starting last month.
She added: “The November commentary is the latest step in 18 months of consistent policy.
“It asks for the one thing the public has still not been given — the evidence behind a facilities charge that rose from $52.48 to $148.83 a month for every household with solar panels, whatever the size of the system.”
The ministry spokeswoman acknowledged the RA’s independence, but added it was still beholden to Section 8(5) of the Electricity Act 2016, which ordered it to act “in accordance with any ministerial directions”.
She also cited Section 15 of the Act and the Regulatory Authority Act 2011, both of which further demanded conformity with directions and being mindful of “prices and affordability” for consumers.
The spokeswoman added: “A direction for fairer cost allocation is not a licence to nearly triple a charge.”
She explained: “The authority raised the fixed charge in every residential tier by about 23 per cent and placed every solar household in the highest consumption tier.
“Its own consultant projected that more than nine in ten residential solar customers would pay more.
“Bermuda waited seven years between approved resource plans while a renewable target that was never costed sat on the books.”
The spokeswoman further urged Mr Robinson to “choose a position” when questioning if the ministry would issue directions for a “less punitive” solar charge while “questioning ministerial interference”.
She added: “Dialogue and accountability must coexist.
“The May 2025 direction followed consultation with the authority in April. The authority regulates tariffs. Belco must account for its costs.
“The ministry sets national policy and advocates for the public interest.
“Asking in public for the evidence behind a charge is not fighting in the media. It is what accountability looks like when the public is paying the bill.”
The spokeswoman said: “Bermudians deserve to understand what their Government is doing, why decisions are being made and how that work will improve affordability.
“The question now before the Regulatory Authority and Belco is the one the minister has asked since July — show the evidence.”
See Opinion for Mr Robinson’s full article
