Personal trainer not guilty of intrusion allegations
A personal trainer accused of acting inappropriately with two female clients has been acquitted of all charges in the Magistrates’ Court.
The defendant, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, was found not guilty of charges that he sexually assaulted one woman and intruded on the privacy of a second in separate incidents in October 2024.
Delivering her ruling, magistrate Auralee Cassidy told the court that she found one of the accusers was not a truthful witness, while the second had willingly taken down her own clothing for “progress pictures”.
In all the circumstances, she said that the Crown had not proven either of the charges.
The first of the two complainants alleged that the man had pulled her underwear while taking “progress pictures” — intended to show progress the clients had made in their training — in an incident on October 1, 2024.
The second alleged that the defendant had instructed her to take off her bottoms for progress pictures that same month, claiming that he had told her that she was the only one he “made” do so.
However, taking the stand in his own defence in September, the defendant denied all the allegations, stating that they were “absolutely not true”.
While he accepted that he had taken progress pictures, he said he always told clients that the decision to take pictures, or what to wear in the pictures, was entirely up to them.
He said the first incident never took place, and he had never instructed the second to take down her bottoms, stating he was “surprised” when she did so.
The defendant said he did speak to the complainant later stating she was the only person who took the pictures without underwear, but denied that he had ever made her do so.
Delivering her verdict today, Ms Cassidy said the woman who accused the defendant of pulling her underwear was not a “witness of truth”.
Regarding the second complainant, she found that a person voluntarily taking down her clothing for progress pictures did not amount to an “intrusion” under the Act.
She added: “The comment made to the complainant was not done for the purpose of embarrassment, but to ensure that she was aware she did not need to expose as much of her personal areas to make the progress pictures.”
Ms Cassidy said she was satisfied that the defendant only took photographs to the degree necessary to record the woman’s progress and his action were not intended to alarm or offend.
As a result, she acquitted the defendant of both charges.
• It is The Royal Gazette’s policy not to allow comments on stories regarding court cases. As we are legally liable for any libellous or defamatory comments made on our website, this move is for our protection as well as that of our readers
