Rev. Goodwin Smith is to be replaced as the chairman of the Human Rights Commission.

New Minister of Community Affairs Randolph Horton confirmed reports that the clergyman will not be reappointed as Commission chair when the board's term ends at year end.

"It's just a part of the natural thing that's done each year," he said when asked why the decision had been taken.

"Appointments are made and not everybody is reappointed."

Rev Smith was "not available" when The Royal Gazette called for comment last night.

Mr. Horton said that the decision not to reappoint him should not be read as a reflection of his performance during Rev. Smith's two year tenure.

"It was just decided we would look to do something a little different.

"He's made a very significant and positive contribution to the board."

Mr. Horton said that no decision had yet been taken as to his replacement.

But he said he had a personal preference for somebody with legal experience.

"But that's not necessarily going to be the case."

Asked if the decision was handled cordially he said "absolutely."

He added that he was "comfortable" with the decision.

"You do what you think is in the best interest of the people," said the Minister.

Rev Smith's appointment in 1999 stirred some controversy because he had publicly opposed the Stubbs bill which decriminalised homosexuality.

More recently he supported a controversial decision by CedarBridge principal Kalmar Richards not to allow the Harry Potter children's books to be taught at the school.