Accused's character `impeccable'
revealed in Magistrates' Court yesterday.
Simon David Carruthers, of Arlington Avenue, Pembroke, admits he struck Andrew McAllister during an incident outside the Bank of N.T. Butterfield on Front Street last November.
But in court yesterday, defence lawyer Mark Pettingill asked that Magistrate Edward King accept his client's claim that he was provoked by the complainant.
Carruthers, 29 and chef/manager at The Beach restaurant, claims he "snapped and lost self-control'' after his left buttock was groped by Mr. McAllister for a second time.
Mr. McAllister required surgery after receiving a blow to the face by the accused, resulting in three fractures and a black eye.
With no previous arrests or convictions, Carruthers described himself as "definitely not a violent person''.
In his closing remarks to the court during yesterday's hearing, Mr. Pettingill said: "He is a young man of impeccable character.'' Carruthers plays for the Bermuda Police Rugby Football Club, and is "high up in the sport'', according to Mr. Pettingill.
Having never been disciplined in rugby, Carruthers is considered "a fair and sportsmanlike player''.
The defendant is also active on the local cricket, darts and fishing scenes.
In his defence, Mr. Pettingill cited his client's decision not to retaliate after McAllister first grabbed his buttock in the Oasis Night Club, despite "feeling very upset and angry after the incident''.
"I was very shocked and couldn't believe it was happening to me,'' said Carruthers, who immediately walked away.
A decision will be given in Magistrates' Court next Monday. If convicted, Carruthers could face up to a year behind bars.
