Log In

Reset Password

Worrell murder conviction quashed by Court of Appeal

Kamal Worrell (file photograph)

The Court of Appeal has quashed the murder conviction of Kamal Worrell for the 2020 death of Chavelle Dillon-Burgess and substituted a conviction of manslaughter.

Ian Kawaley, president of the Court of appeal, said that no retrial would be ordered and a date would be set for Worrell to be resentenced.

Worrell remains remanded in custody.

Cindy Clarke, the Director of Public Prosecutions, said in court that the rationale behind allowing the appeal against the murder conviction was that the directions given to the jury on the subject of manslaughter were “incomplete”.

She said: “The judge did not produce examples to the jury of evidence that would best support manslaughter as opposed to murder.”

In January 2024, Worrell was found guilty by majority verdict of murdering Ms Dillon-Burgess, the mother of his child, on an unknown date between April 10 and June 11, 2020.

He was further convicted of six counts of common assault by unanimous verdict and one count by majority verdict.

Ms Dillon-Burgess was reported missing by her family on April 30, 2020, and has still not been found despite island-wide searches.

Worrell maintained his innocence, telling the Supreme Court during his trial that Ms Dillon-Burgess had walked out of the home that they shared with their child after an argument on April 11, 2020.

He said she briefly returned days later only to collect personal items, but he had not seen her since.

Worrell claimed that he had never acted violently towards Ms Dillon-Burgess and had only ever acted to defend himself when she lashed out at him.

However, prosecutors suggested that Worrell felt as though Ms Dillon-Burgess was ruining his career with her allegations of violence and urged the jury to consider his actions before and after her disappearance.

Worrell was found guilty by a jury and subsequently sentenced to serve at least 27 years of a life sentence behind bars for murder and an additional six months for the assault charges.

However, complaints were raised in the Court of Appeal that evidence in the case had been disclosed late while other evidence available to the parties should have been put before the jury.

Richard Horseman, for Worrell, argued that the assault charges had tainted the murder conviction and challenged the directions given to the jury by Puisne Judge Juan Wolffe about the alternative charge of manslaughter.

In a written judgment, written by Mr Justice Kawaley, the Court of Appeal dismissed most of the grounds of appeal but found weight in the arguments against Mr Justice Wolffe’s manslaughter directions.

The judgment said: “The problem with these directions is not that it was impossible for the jury to potentially infer the requisite intent from the evidence the prosecution relied upon.

“The problem lies in the fact that, as the judge properly directed at the outset, adverse inferences can only be drawn against the accused where they are the only reasonable inference, and reaching such a conclusion requires the jury to evaluate competing potential inferences with reference to the factual matrices of the present case.

“In this instance, the possibility that the appellant had killed the victim unlawfully without intending to murder her or cause her grievous bodily harm was far from a fanciful one.

“There was evidence that Chavelle, despite her diminutive stature compared to the appellant, was physically aggressive and that he would subdue her by lying on top of her, making it impossible for her to breathe.

“By the appellant’s own account he was not stupid enough to inflict physical injuries on her.”

The court noted that, as Mr Horseman had pointed out, even if Ms Dillon-Burgess was killed accidentally, the appellant may have feared that no one would believe his explanation and sought to conceal her death.

The judgment continued: “The jury were not assisted to evaluate the murder/manslaughter options with practical evidential examples. Only the prosecution’s examples were put.

“Because the appellant was hoping to be acquitted of both murder and manslaughter, he gambled on not inviting the jury to consider the alternative verdict option. But the judge was obliged to put the manslaughter option fairly and squarely before the jury in a fact-focused manner.”

The court allowed the appeal on the grounds of the “unfair” manslaughter direction and quashed the appeal for murder, but dismissed all the other grounds of appeal.

The judgment noted that in the wake of the decision, counsel for both the Crown and Worrell were contacted about how the matter should be disposed of.

Under the Court of Appeal Act, the court could acquit Worrell altogether, order a retrial for murder or substitute a conviction for manslaughter.

The Crown submitted that, given the finding of the jury, a substitution for manslaughter was preferred.

Summarising her submissions in court, Ms Clarke said: “The finding of the jury was that the appellant did in fact commit a homicide, causing the unlawful death of Chavelle Dillon-Burgess.

“We thought that in all the circumstances of this case that it would be best to honour that finding by substituting manslaughter.”

Mr Horseman meanwhile said Worrell would accept the substitution of a conviction of manslaughter and agreed that the court should impose a fresh sentence.

• UPDATE: this article has been updated with additional information from court

• It is The Royal Gazette’s policy not to allow comments on stories regarding court cases. As we are legally liable for any libellous or defamatory comments made on our website, this move is for our protection as well as that of our readers