Orbis opposes Canon's takeover bid for Dutch printer maker
NEW YORK (Bloomberg) — Bermuda-based Orbis Funds, the asset manager that opposed takeover offers by Warren Buffett and Citigroup Inc., rejected Canon Inc.'s 730 million euro ($1.1 billion) bid to buy unprofitable Dutch printer maker Oce NV as too low.
Canon's 8.60 euros-a-share offer "significantly undervalues" Oce's assets, and Orbis doesn't want to sell its stake of about 10 percent at that price, the Bermuda-based manager of $20 billion in assets said in a statement yesterday. Canon said its bid was sufficient and Oce declined to comment.
The opposition pits Canon, the world's largest maker of office equipment, against a fund that challenged Buffett's bid for Clayton Homes Inc. in 2003 and led investors in pressuring Citigroup to raise its offer for Nikko Cordial Corp. two years ago. Canon earlier this week said it agreed to buy Venlo, Netherlands-based Oce to expand its printer operations.
"Opposition by such a major shareholder could result in delays and negative consequences for the deal," Osamu Hirose, an analyst at Tokai Tokyo Securities who rates Canon shares "neutral," said by phone yesterday. "With Oce's recent earnings in a slump, it might be tough to find a bidder who will offer a better premium."
In 2007, Orbis led investors in Japanese brokerage Nikko Cordial to press Citigroup to raise a $13.4 billion bid by offering to sell their shares at a higher price than the US bank was paying. Berkshire Hathaway Inc., controlled by billionaire investor Buffett, was opposed by a group of Clayton investors including Orbis in 2003 over its bid for mobile-home maker Clayton. Orbis's group said then Buffett's fund was taking advantage of a drop in mobile-homes sales to buy the company cheaply. The deal was completed after the Tennessee Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal by one of the investors.
Oce's review process of the Canon bid was "careful and complete", the company said in a statement yesterday. Oce has had "frequent contact with all relevant industry players" and discussed various possible transactions before deciding on Canon.
Konica Minolta Holdings Inc., the Japanese lens and office-equipment maker that has a business partnership with Oce, said yesterday it has no plan to counter Canon's offer.
Canon fell 0.3 percent to 3,460 yen on the Tokyo Stock Exchange. Oce added 0.3 percent, to 8.60 euros in Amsterdam trading. It surged 70 percent on November 16 after Canon announced its offer.
"We believe that our offer, as was agreed by Oce's management and supervisory boards, is sufficient," Canon said in an e-mailed statement yesterday.
Ducatus NV, ASR Nederland NV and ING Groep NV, which represent about 19 percent of Oce's share capital, have agreed to sell their stakes to Canon, Oce said on November 16.