Allshores executive pledges to cut premiums if claims fall
If health insurance claims fall, premiums will follow suit, the head of Allshores’ health insurance business vowed yesterday.
Peter Lozier, the insurer’s group head of benefits, was put on the spot in a question-and-answer session at the Caribbean Conference on National Health-Financing Initiatives at the Hamilton Princess & Beach Club yesterday.
Asked whether Allshores was able to make a profit out of health insurance, Mr Lozier said the insurer made a margin of between 5 per cent and 8 per cent.
“We spend about $360 million a year in claims in Bermuda,” Mr Lozier said. “About 85 cents of every dollar of premium that comes in goes out in claims.”
When it came to containing healthcare costs, he said, it made more sense to focus on reducing the 85 cents of claims, rather than the nickel on the dollar of profit.
“There is a lot of opportunity to adjust the overall spend as a result of better outcomes, to lower that cost,” he said.
“The magic is managing that 85 cents. If we can turn that 85 cents into 80 cents, the premium will follow.” Mr Lozier said that by managing claims, he did not mean cutting services, but rather improving outcomes.
A delegate asked him to confirm that a fall in claims would lead to a reduction in premiums.
“One hundred per cent,” Mr Lozier replied. “You can take me to the bank on that, guys.”
He added that Allshores’ clients had full transparency on this, as they each saw how much premium went to Allshores and how much was paid in claims.
The questioner added that he was pleased to hear this, as there was a perception that insurance companies would never reduce premiums, once they had gone up.
In his earlier presentation at the conference, Mr Lozier offered some statistics that shed light on Allshores’ significance to the island’s healthcare system.
The company insures about 80 per cent of members of private health insurance plans in Bermuda, and through its acquisition of medical practices, represents about half of the island’s primary care physicians, he said.
With this level of responsibility, insurers could no longer be passive in simply collecting premiums and paying claims. “It’s no longer appropriate for insurers to behave that way,” Mr Lozier said.
The concern over healthcare costs meant difficult conversations with clients, with healthcare inflation driving premiums up by double-digit percentages.
One opportunity was in chronic disease management, he said. “You get back about $1.50 for every dollar you put into it,” he said. “It’s something we all know about, but we don’t do enough of.”
One of the main reasons was that chronic disease management was, for the most part, not a billable charge. “Providers aren’t doing it, because they can’t bill for it,” he added.
He cited Allshores’ Diabetes Rewind Programme as an example of how this approach could be successful.
“The insurance company pays 100 per cent of the cost associated with diabetes care, including the food,” Mr Lozier explained. Focused resources and partnerships with entities including the Bermuda Diabetes Association had yielded positive results, he added.
Data played a key part in recognising opportunities to reduce costs, said Mr Lozier, adding that about 20 per cent of people insured generated some 80 per cent of claims.
The cost of drugs is also playing a more significant role in overall healthcare costs.
“Pharmacy is now equal in size to hospital spend for us,” he added. About 30 per cent of the pharmacy spending was associated with 3 per cent of the drugs, he added.
Proactively working to keep people healthy is Allshores’ focus. Mr Lozier added: “Value-based care is all about the outcome — and lower cost is the result of achieving that.”
