Log In

Reset Password

Trial ends for woman accused of threatening magistrate

A police officer who reportedly heard someone threaten to shoot a magistrate had no reason to lie to the court, a prosecutor said yesterday.

Linton Robinson told acting magistrate Timothy Marshall that Pc Julia Swan cared about the best interests of Stephanie Hollis on the day that the latter allegedly made the threat.

Ms Hollis, 40, is accused of threatening to injure magistrate Maria Sofianos on account of something she did as a holder of a judicial office.

Earlier in the trial, Pc Swan said she heard Ms Hollis say “something to the effect of ‘if I see that woman on the street, I will shoot her in the head’ ” while in the Dame Lois Browne-Evans building on February 4.

Presenting his closing argument in the trial yesterday, Mr Robinson said: “No motive was established for [Pc Swan] to lie in this case.”

He added that the officer warned Ms Hollis to stay calm before she entered Ms Sofianos’s courtroom on the day of the alleged incident.

The magistrate later instructed police not to allow Ms Hollis back into her courtroom after she stormed out.

Mr Robinson also highlighted that Ms Hollis repeatedly claimed that Ms Sofianos had a “vendetta” against her during an interview with police.

Jonathan White, Ms Hollis’s lawyer, submitted yesterday that Pc Swan, the only person who heard Ms Hollis make the threat, was a “wholly unreliable” witness.

He added that the court could not be sure that his client threatened anyone at all, or that any alleged threat was directed specifically at Ms Sofianos.

Mr White also said that Ms Hollis was not on trial for disliking Ms Sofianos and that “animosity is not de facto that a threat is made”.

Mr Marshall is expected to rule on the case on December 2 and extended Ms Hollis’s bail until that time.

• It is The Royal Gazette’s policy not to allow comments on stories regarding court cases. As we are legally liable for any slanderous or defamatory comments made on our website, this move is for our protection as well as that of our readers