Log In

Reset Password

Paolo Odoli: A new structure is not enough

The Education Authority Bill returns to the House of Assembly on Friday.

As I read it, the Bill will essentially assemble the team that will eventually deliver education reform. I am managing my expectations about what it will deliver.

Bermuda has been here before. Nearly two decades ago, the Hopkins Report examined the island’s education system and identified serious weaknesses in its leadership, governance and performance.

But the report did not only identify problems with how the system was managed; it also found that there were no commonly agreed criteria for determining whether a child had learning difficulties or was simply considered hard to teach. Nineteen years later, that question remains relevant as Bermuda considers how its education system should identify and support children who learn differently.

The Bill is, in part, an attempt to address the structural problems identified in the report. There is a case for changing how the system is managed and how it is held accountable. But there is another question that deserves to be asked as the Bill moves through the legislative process: what will the new structure actually be required to do for the children it serves?

A system can be reorganised, its responsibilities redistributed and its reporting arrangements strengthened. None of that necessarily means a child who is struggling to read, write, concentrate or keep up with classmates will be identified any earlier, or receive the support they need. That distinction matters.

The point is not that nothing has changed since 2007, nor that the proposed Education Authority has no merit. The Bill establishes a new body with responsibilities for education reform, leadership capability, whole-school improvement, professional development, inclusivity, engagement with parents and students, and the use of data to inform decisions. But on reform, its work goes back to the minister in the form of recommendations, which need a second Bill to take effect.

The proposed authority will also have a framework for reporting on its performance and progress. There is a legitimate argument that a more coherent structure, with clearer lines of responsibility, could help Bermuda address problems that have persisted for years.

But governance and outcomes are not interchangeable. A system can become better organised without necessarily becoming better at recognising the needs of an individual child.

Consider children whose difficulties are not immediately obvious. Some may be disruptive; others may withdraw. Some may struggle to read or write, while others can appear to be keeping up until the demands of school become more complicated. A child with an attention or language-based learning difference may spend years being described as lazy, careless, unmotivated or simply not applying themselves.

The question is not whether every child who struggles has a diagnosable condition. It is whether the education system is equipped to recognise when a child needs additional support and whether that support can begin before a formal diagnosis is obtained.

One school in Bermuda shows what that support can achieve. The Bermuda Centre for Creative Learning, a private school for children with learning differences such as dyslexia and ADHD, reports that historically an average of 46 per cent of its students have come from the public school system.

Over the past two years, the school reports, its students averaged 1.10 year levels of growth annually in English and 1.08 in mathematics. In a single school year, 17.6 per cent of students in English and 18.5 per cent in mathematics gained two or more year levels.

These are the school’s own figures, drawn from a specialist intake, and should not be treated as representative of Bermuda’s wider student population. They are not conclusive evidence of what would happen across the public system. But they are instructive: they suggest what can be possible when children receive support suited to how they learn. For a child who has been falling behind, making substantial progress in a year is meaningful change.

Lindsey Sirju, the school’s cofounder and head, said the wording of the Bill was a matter for legislators. What matters, she said, is that the needs of children with learning differences “are recognised and supported, regardless of the education system they attend”.

The cost of getting this wrong is not only educational. I have written previously that families can spend years trying to understand why their child is struggling, navigating assessments and seeking support. Where specialist learning support is needed, the financial burden can be substantial and exclusionary. And where help arrives late, the effects may reach beyond the classroom, affecting a child’s confidence, relationships and willingness to engage with school.

I am not arguing against diagnosis. A proper assessment can be valuable, sometimes essential. It can help explain a child’s difficulties and identify the support that is likely to work. But diagnosis should not become the price of admission to help.

That principle was expressed clearly in Westminster Hall recently during a debate on neurodiversity and the role of government. Responding to concerns about long waits for ADHD and autism assessments, Parliamentary secretary Sally Jameson said: “Support is too often organised around diagnosis, rather than people’s needs and circumstances.”

She described a move towards a needs-led approach, with earlier access to information, support and intervention, rather than making families wait for a diagnostic assessment before anything can happen.

The Education Authority Bill provides an opportunity to make that principle part of the system Bermuda is building. As drafted, it gives the authority broad responsibilities for reform and support. It provides for one board member to have expertise in supporting vulnerable and at-risk students. It also provides for school-based health services, including screening and allied health services such as speech and language therapy, occupational therapy and physical therapy.

Those provisions matter. But they are not the same as a clear statutory obligation to identify and respond to additional learning needs across the school system, including where a child has not received a formal diagnosis.

There are three areas where the legislation, or the work that follows it, could and should be clearer.

First, there should be an explicit expectation that children’s additional learning needs are identified and addressed on the basis of need, not made conditional on a diagnosis. That does not mean schools should be expected to diagnose medical or developmental conditions. It means they should be able to recognise difficulties, respond appropriately and provide support while further assessment is considered.

Second, there needs to be a systematic approach to identifying children who may be struggling. That could include age-appropriate screening and regular checks, provided there is a clear plan for what happens when a concern is identified. Screening without the resources or capacity to follow up risks becoming another exercise in recording problems without resolving them. But relying only on the children who fall far enough behind, or become distressed enough, to attract attention is not an adequate strategy either.

As Darrien Ray, a registered Bermuda psychologist, cautioned, an approach focused on vulnerable or at-risk students can leave support services vulnerable to overfocusing on the “squeaky wheels”. He illustrated the danger with the example of a mechanic who fixes a broken front light but fails to check the oil. The immediate problem may have been addressed but a more serious one can remain unnoticed.

Third, the timetable must be real. Under the Bill, the board has 18 months from the commencement of the relevant provisions to submit its recommendations. The commencement date itself is to be appointed by the minister and the Bill allows different provisions to come into force at different times. The minister must then bring forward legislation implementing the recommendations or explain the delay and provide updates.

This is a framework for accountability but families should be able to see when the clock starts, what milestones will follow and how progress will be measured. The Bill requires the authority’s annual operating plan to discuss any quantitative indicators it has adopted to measure its performance. It does not prescribe which indicators must be adopted.

Quarterly reports to the minister must cover student outcomes but the legislation does not specify measures for establishing whether children are being identified earlier or making better progress. Those are choices the authority will have to make, and they should be made deliberately.

I do not expect the Bill to be changed in these ways when debate resumes. I hope to be proved wrong.

A new authority may be the right answer to some of the problems identified in Bermuda’s education system. But changing the structure is not the same as changing the experience of the child sitting in the classroom.

The test of this legislation will not simply be whether the new organisation is established, whether its board meets or whether it produces its recommendations on time. It will be whether children who need help are recognised before years of struggle have convinced them that school is somewhere they do not belong.

A child should not have to fail before the system recognises that they need help. Nor should a family have to afford a diagnosis before that help becomes available.

Bermuda has an opportunity to build something better. It should make sure the new structure is required to do more than manage the system. It must help the system see the children within it.

• Paolo Odoli was aide-de-camp to two governors of Bermuda and is a former government communications officer. He lives in northern Italy with his family

Royal Gazette has implemented platform upgrades, requiring users to utilize their Royal Gazette Account Login to comment on Disqus for enhanced security. To create an account, click here.

You must be Registered or to post comment or to vote.

Published November 17, 2026 at 7:54 am (Updated November 17, 2026 at 7:29 am)

Paolo Odoli: A new structure is not enough

Users agree to adhere to our Online User Conduct for commenting and user who violate the Terms of Service will be banned.