Log In

Reset Password

Court rules against PLP on retroactive membership changes

Curtis Dickinson as he formally throws his hat in the ring in the bid for the leadership of the Progressive Labour Party (File photograph by Akil Simmons)

The Supreme Court has ruled in favour of a former finance minister in a legal dispute that could decide the fate of the Progressive Labour Party’s leadership race.

A copy of a civil ruling from the Supreme Court, seen by The Royal Gazette, was issued by Puisne Judge Shade Subair Williams. The document has not been officially made public.

The judgment finds largely in favour of Curtis Dickinson, who is challenging Jason Hayward, the Minister of Economy and Labour, for leadership of the governing party.

Mr Dickinson and others filed legal action to seek “urgent relief” to block progress on a membership process that he alleged was contrary to the party’s constitution.

The case concerned two proposed amendments — one which moved that people who publicly campaigned against the party in the past two consecutive elections be prevented from automatically becoming members, and another which proposed that only those who were members for at least a year be permitted to vote for the party leader in the delegates’ conference.

A central committee meeting passed the amendments on August 24.

Mrs Justice Subair Williams wrote: “On the basic facts of this case, there is dissension internal to the Progressive Labour Party and some of its members as to the proper application of the Progressive Labour Party’s constitution and its bylaws governing its membership process.

“Strife is further marked by a divergence of views between the parties as to the scope of the party’s powers to alter or otherwise interfere with the contractual rights of persons who became or were entitled to become members on or between 1 September, 2025, and 31 August, 2026.”

She noted in her judgment that the PLP’s constitution does not allow the central committee to restrict anyone aged 18 or older who submitted an application from becoming a party member.

The judge added that the second proposal, concerning who can and cannot be delegates at the party’s conference, attempted to go against another part of the party’s constitution.

Mrs Justice Subair Williams concluded that both the proposed amendments were invalid and, according to the PLP constitution, unlawful, as they would need to be approved by two thirds of the delegates present at an annual general or special delegates’ conference.

She also wrote in the 85-page document that no amendment to the PLP constitution adopted after August 31 could allow the party to “lawfully limit or remove any membership rights acquired by any individual who obtained or was entitled to obtain membership” on or by that date.

Mrs Justice Subair Williams ruled that membership forms received on or before August 31 could be refused only if it could not be confirmed that the member directly or indirectly submitted the membership form, or that the applicant was at least 18 years old.

However, she found that the party was not prevented from implementing the amendments in the case of members whose applications were submitted after August 31.

Mrs Justice Subair Williams addressed the matter of bulk payments paid by Mr Dickinson’s campaign team.

She ruled: “Payment of membership dues are required of members, not applicants, seeking to become financial members of the party.

“The 28 July, 2026, bulk payment totalling $18,775 in dues … which was transferred from the personal bank account of the fourth plaintiff … is attributable to the individual applicants in respect of the 655 general membership applications and 24 lifetime membership applications.

“Those applicants are entitled to be confirmed (if not already confirmed) as financial members, subject to the exercise of a lawful verification process.

“No issue was taken as to the original source of payment of the remaining four transfers contributing to the total sum of $45,845 paid in by Mr Dickinson’s campaign.”

The judge also found: “The party is entitled to regulate its own administrative processes for verifying the submission of membership forms, so long as the verification requirements do not infringe on the membership criteria prescribed by Article IV of the PLP constitution.”

Mrs Justice Subair Williams granted the plaintiffs, listed in the summons as Mr Dickinson, Sheila Maureen Brown, Jay-lee Maurice Smith, Winifred Rose Stevens and Shea-Tai Maurice Smith, costs “on a standard basis in respect of the trial of the originating summons”.

However, she granted costs of an application that underpinned an earlier ruling to the defendants, listed as Dawn Simmons, the PLP chairwoman, and the party’s secretary-general, Patricia Basden.

The judgment showed that in a sworn affidavit Ms Simmons had noted: “The submissions of thousands of new membership application forms and membership dues during the lead-up to the scheduled annual general conference is at a level that has never been seen before in the history of the Bermuda Progressive Labour Party.

“As the chairperson of the party, I deem this to be an extraordinary situation, one that the party constitution, the supporting processes or party’s volunteer resources had [not] anticipated.”

Mrs Justice Subair Williams ruled that a list of people who became party members between September 1, 2025, and August 31, 2026, must be provided by the defendants to the plaintiffs’ lawyers by 4pm on November 13.

A statement released by the PLP on behalf of Ms Simmons said that the party received a copy of the Supreme Court ruling.

“The party respects the court and will review the judgment with counsel,” it added.

“A further statement will be issued once the review is complete.”

The campaign team for Mr Dickinson was also asked for comment but the Gazette was told there would be none for the time being.

• It is The Royal Gazette’s policy not to allow comments on stories regarding court cases. As we are legally liable for any libellous or defamatory comments made on our website, this move is for our protection as well as that of our readers