Log In

Reset Password

Spiritual, but not religious?

Nature’s glory: many people say they can feel spiritual, but not religious, for example when they gaze at a beautiful sunset (Adobe stock image)

If you take a look at recent surveys like from Pew Research Centre, 22 per cent of those questioned in the United States of America identify as “spiritual but not religious” when it comes to their belief system.

What that means is that they do have a sense for spirituality, however, don’t express this by participating in a religion or faith community.

While we are not part of the US, I can imagine that a survey here would show something similar. There is a growing number of people who have no affiliation to any of our churches or other places of worship, who follow no holy book, and have no spiritual mentors, pastors, rabbis, priests or teachers.

I met some people who told me they get spiritual experiences in nature, like looking at an old tree, the starry night sky or a Bermuda sunset, listening to music or experience a piece of art or a performance.

I can relate to having an uplifting feeling and deep sense of being when I experience those phenomena. When the Bermuda evening sky turns pink and orange with Chagall-type feather clouds and the endless motion of the ocean beneath, I get still inside, too, and wonder about the beauty of creation.

There are days when my darling and I travel to the special spots to see it, like Spanish Point, Fort St Catherine, Whale Bay or Daniel’s Head and I ponder that I am part of this universe.

When I read scientific explanations of planet movement, stars, and galaxies, about organelles in our cells, DNA and symbiotic processes in nature, I am in awe, too.

As I am a religious person as well, I relate all of these beautiful, indescribable moments to my faith. I recall the beginning of Psalm 8. King David expressed his awe in it: “Lord, our Lord, how majestic is your name in all the Earth! You have set your glory in the heavens. Through the praise of children and infants you have established a stronghold against your enemies, to silence the foe and the avenger.

“When I consider your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have set in place, what is mankind that you are mindful of them, human beings that you care for them? You have made them a little lower than the angels and crowned them with glory and honour. You made them rulers over the works of your hands …” (verses 1-6, NIV)

It talks about the unbelievable relationship between the Almighty and his unfathomable universe and us humans. I believe we are relational beings, we need relationships with each other and with that one we believe to be higher and beyond.

For me, Church has always been a meeting place to make those relations possible. It was through others that I learnt to express my deep inner feelings, to put them into a bigger context, and develop a system of belief. The really important things we cannot tell ourselves, they are awarded to us.

Having said that, I also must admit I have been in worship services and Church communities, who would have fit the category “religious, but not spiritual”. They were sad and dull.

Even the deepest texts like the Lord’s Prayer or the Apostle’s Creed were read fast and without any emphasis, the sermon read like a manual for a new fridge and the singing without any joy. Religious, but not spiritual.

In Matthew 25 Jesus tells the Parable of the Ten Bridesmaids. They were waiting outside the town in the evening to welcome the groom, who came from another town, to lead him to his new home to celebrate the wedding, an oriental custom in those days.

They had oil lamps with them to illuminate the way. However, the parable says, five of them were foolish and had no oil to refill their lamps, while the other five had planned ahead.

Somehow the arrival was delayed, and the lamps burnt out. Now the foolish bridesmaids had to go and find more oil.

While they were gone, the groom arrived and the remaining five bridesmaids led him to the wedding house. The foolish missed it, and consequently they missed out on the wedding, as the door was shut.

To me those foolish bridesmaids are what I would call religious but not spiritual. They had nothing to get the fire going. They wanted to be part of the celebration and of the joy, they had their lamps and in the beginning even some oil and light, but then they dried up.

I personally need more than being spiritual or religious by itself, I need both intertwined. Without the spiritual part the lamp runs dry, it is dull and empty, like steps without music don’t make a good dance.

On the other hand, without the religious part, I feel alone, small and deprived of meaning beyond me. Where are the others to dance with?

Being religious and spiritual means more than just going through the motion or having a touchy feeling. It is about being whole. Some of our churches and religious bodies might have to work on their spiritual side, and at the same time I pray for some of those “spiritual but not religious” individuals to find ways to put their spirituality into a context that is beyond their own horizon, so that we can translate the spiritual feeling into trust, faith, love and relationship, into a hope that is based on more than just a beautiful sunset.

I am thankful for being brought up within the Christian Church. Others have passed on to me what had given their spirituality expression and substance. We need others to teach us, the Bible to reveal God to us, the faith of sisters and brothers to help us to build this relationship with God and our neighbours.

I am convinced God allowed to have so many denominations and churches so that everybody could find a place that helps to put their spirituality into context. All kinds of churches for all kinds of people.

Just like looking for a good pair of shoes we cannot give up on shoes just because the first pair was to small or uncomfortable. We all would walk barefoot. That is OK for a while when the sun shines, but in rough weather or difficult terrain the right shoes can come in very handy.

Spiritual but not religious sounds to me like living barefoot. It may feel good and be OK while the sun shines. However, we also need shoes for the other times.

• Karsten Decker is an ordained Lutheran pastor and novelist from Germany who has lived and worked in Bermuda since 2001. At the moment he helps the Centenary Methodist Church at Collectors Hill as pulpit supply.

Royal Gazette has implemented platform upgrades, requiring users to utilize their Royal Gazette Account Login to comment on Disqus for enhanced security. To create an account, click here.

You must be Registered or to post comment or to vote.

Published November 21, 2026 at 7:20 am (Updated November 21, 2026 at 7:20 am)

Spiritual, but not religious?

Users agree to adhere to our Online User Conduct for commenting and user who violate the Terms of Service will be banned.