Sentence reduced for child sex offender
The Court of Appeal has reduced the 16-year sentence of a man convicted of sexually exploiting a child on the basis that it was excessive compared to other cases.
Maleke Martin was convicted in 2022 of two counts of sexual exploitation of a young person by someone in a position of trust and one count of showing offensive material to a child.
He was sentenced in 2023, at the age of 26, to imprisonment for 13½ years, 16 years and six years respectively, to run concurrently for a total of 16 years, with that sentence to be followed by a 15-year supervision order.
However, he launched an appeal arguing that the sentence was excessive and the judge had incorrectly interpreted evidence to suggest he had groomed the victim.
In a decision handed down on Friday, the Court of Appeal rejected the argument that the judge had sentenced Martin on the wrong factual basis or that she had “exaggerated” the incidents.
However, the court accepted that the sentence was “out of kilter” with sentences imposed in other cases, reducing the overall sentence to one of 12 years and cutting the supervision order to ten years.
The Supreme Court heard during his trial in 2022 that Martin moved in with the victim’s family, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, in August 2020.
In October that year, the victim told her grandmother that Martin had showed her an inappropriate video and had her perform lewd acts while instructing her not to tell other people.
A police investigation into the allegations was launched and Martin was arrested and charged in March 2021.
He denied all the charges but was found guilty on all counts by a jury in December 2022.
Puisne Judge Shade Subair Williams, the trial judge, said that Martin had “single-handedly used his position to exploit a child and ruin her life”.
Mrs Justice Subair Williams sentenced Martin to 16 years behind bars, ordering that he serve at least eight years before becoming eligible for parole
The sentence was ordered to be followed by a 15-year supervision order, with Martin placed on the sex offenders register.
In November 2025, Elizabeth Christopher, for Martin, argued that the sentence was “extraordinary” and that there was nothing to support a 15-year supervision order after his period of incarceration.
She also argued that there was no evidence that Martin had “groomed” the victim.
Cindy Clarke, the Director of Public Prosecutions, noted that legislators had increased penalties for sexual offences to reflect public sentiment and it would be wrong to shorten the sentence because “undue leniency” was given in another case.
In a judgment written by Justice of Appeal Elizabeth Gloster, the Court of Appeal found that the judge was justified to find Martin was grooming the victim given the evidence in the case.
While the court agreed with Ms Christopher that the sentence of 16 years was manifestly excessive compared to other cases, it disagreed with the appellant’s suggestion that a sentence of five to seven years was appropriate, stating that did not reflect the seriousness of the offence.
The court accordingly reduced the sentences for the two counts of sexual exploitation to ten years and 12 years in prison respectively.
Mrs Justice Gloster also found that the 15-year supervision order imposed was “excessive and disproportionate”, stating: “There was no justification for extending the period of supervision beyond the mandatory period.
“There was no evidence to suggest that the risk would not be reduced to an acceptable level within ten years but would be reduced to such a level after 15 years.
“Accordingly, I would allow the appeal to the extent of reducing the period of the supervision order from 15 years to ten years.”
However, the court upheld the decision to order that Martin must serve at least half of his sentence before he becomes eligible for parole.
Mrs Justice Gloster wrote: “Although it is the position that not all child sex offenders are subject to the restriction that they have to serve 50 per cent of their sentence before applying for parole, in the present case the judge, who had heard the evidence at trial was, in my view, clearly entitled to come to the conclusion that the applicant’s conduct was such as to justify such an order.
“I would not be minded to interfere with her conclusion in this respect.”
• It is The Royal Gazette’s policy not to allow comments on stories regarding court cases. As we are legally liable for any libellous or defamatory comments made on our website, this move is for our protection as well as that of our readers
