Hamilton and the implosion of the American Left
Hey, Democrats, want help to rally the country around Donald Trump? Here is a great idea: have a crowd of wealthy, out-of-touch Manhattan liberals, who can afford $849 tickets to Hamilton, boo Vice-President-elect Mike Pence while the cast of the Broadway show lectures him on diversity.
The Democratic Party's alienation from the rest of America was on full display at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on Friday night. And the Left seems oblivious to how ridiculous it looks to the rest of the United States. Professors at Yale and Columbia universities and other elite schools postpone examinations and cancel classes for students who could not deal with the election results. Children in Washington schools cut class with tacit approval from administrators to march in protest of the results of a free and fair election. School officials in suburban DC offer grief counsellors to “help students process any concerns or feelings they have about the election”. Funny, I don't recall anyone cancelling exams or offering my children grief counsellors when Barack Obama was elected.
People in the American heartland see all this, and they shake their heads in disgust. Today's Democrats have become a party of coastal elites completely disconnected from the rest of America. Doubt it? Take a look at a county-by-county map of the 2016 presidential election. You can drive some 3,000 miles across the entire continental US — from sea to shining sea — without driving through a single county that voted for Hillary Clinton.
At the national level, the Democratic Party has been wiped out. Trump won five states that voted for Obama twice — Iowa, Wisconsin, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Florida — pushing Democrats even farther towards the coastal peripheries. As a result, Republicans now control the House, the Senate, the White House, and — after President Trump picks a new justice to replace Antonin Scalia — there will be a restored conservative majority in the Supreme Court. But that is nothing compared with the utter devastation Democrats have suffered in the states. On President Obama's watch, Democrats have lost a net grand total of 939 state legislative seats, 30 state legislative chambers and a dozen governorships. When Obama first took office, Republicans held only 3,223 state legislative seats. After the November 8 vote, the number stands at 4,162. There are now more Republican state legislators than at any time since 1920. And if Governor Pat McCrory holds on in North Carolina, Republicans will match their all-time high of 34 GOP governors — last seen in the 1920s.
Or consider this: today Democrats control both the governor's office and the legislature in only five states — Oregon, California, Hawaii, Connecticut and Rhode Island. By contrast, Republicans have total control of state government in 25 states — half the country.
One Democrat who understands the need to for his party to reconnect with working-class voters in middle America is Tim Ryan, a representative from Ohio, who has challenged Nancy Pelosi for the post of House minority leader. “What we are doing right now is not working,” he wrote in a letter to his colleagues. “Under our current leadership, Democrats have been reduced to our smallest congressional minority since 1929. We have the fewest Democrats in state and federal offices since Reconstruction.”
If Democrats are smart, they will listen to Ryan. His district includes hurting industrial areas such as Youngstown and Akron, so he understands how to win the very voters that Democrats lost in 2016 and need to win back. Do they have a better chance of winning back those voters by electing him or an ageing, coastal San Francisco liberal such as Pelosi?
Ryan is young and dynamic — just 43 years old. The House Democratic leadership, by contrast, is old. The Washington Post recently reported that the average age of the House Democratic leadership is almost 65. And Pelosi is 76, a year older than Bernie Sanders. Perhaps Democrats should take the advice of John F. Kennedy and pass the torch to a new generation.
The long-term problem for Democrats is that much of that new generation has been wiped out at the polls. We saw the impact of the Democratic collapse in the states during this year's presidential primaries. The Republican field was brimming with candidates, while on the Democratic side, Clinton struggled to defeat a dishevelled 75-year-old socialist from Vermont, and the rest of the field — Martin O'Malley, Jim Webb and Lincoln Chafee — could not crack the low single digits.
Eight years of losing statehouses and governors' mansions have left Democrats with no bench. They are like an NFL team with ageing stars who are long past their prime and few prospects in the pipeline.
Democrats may believe that the way back from the periphery is to follow the advice that Aaron Burr offers Hamilton: “Talk less. Smile more. Don't let them know what you're against and what you're for.”
That didn't work out so well for Clinton. If Democrats cannot find new leaders who can connect with the working-class voters they lost to Trump, they may find themselves even more isolated from the American heartland than they are today.
Marc A. Thiessen is a fellow with the American Enterprise Institute and former chief speechwriter to President George W. Bush