Fourth of July spies
DESCRIPTION: Age 3> YearsB>Stature 5Feet<$>7< Inches<$>; Forad<$>fullund<$>; Eyes<$>>blue<$>B>Nose<$><rdinary<$>;
— Signae of the Bearer<$>Albert Fi/I>
Perhaps the official was trained in phrenology, an accepted pseudo-science of the day that suggested that the criminal nature of a person could be determined by bumps on the head, not by so torturing the soul on entry to Bermuda, but by looking at the topography, or landscape, of the skull.
Having a “large” or big mouth would presumably disqualify the visitor from being a spy, but that is exactly what Albert Fitz was on his entry into Bermuda in late 1841.
Following the recent Fourth of July celebrations, where at least 4,000 Bermudians flocked to a party at Dockyard hosted by the US Consul General, the local representative of an enemy of old, it may be of interest to look again at a little known story of Bermuda-United States relations of the early Victorian Age.
We love a good party, of course, and will partake of the table of a foe as fast as we would devour that of a friend. In that nothing much has changed, as Bermudians have excelled at playing both sides for their middlenefit.
Prior to this memorable year, Bermuda was something of a backwater, as the British military and thus the government in England had but a passing interest in the place.
We were already engaged in international business by way of pirating as legal privateers and through trade in the outstanding Bermuda sloop, the fastest ship afloat in its heyday.
Come 1783 and the end of the war with the old East Coast colonies, the British military viewed Bermuda as the perfect replacement for its lost harbours at Boston, New York and elsewhere on that eastern shore.
The TV ad recommends a programme as “a little bit Brit”, in the English affection for puns, but the military airing at Bermuda was a big bit Brit, far outstripping the expenditure at all the other remaining British possessions bordering the Western North Atlantic and the Caribbean.
By the time of the next bash between Britain and America in 1812, the Dockyard was under construction and a series of forts were planned to defend the Narrows Channel and the anchorages at St. George’s.
For 25 years after the War of 1812 things settled down, but hostilities threatened in the early years of Queen Victoria’s reign, with the Canadian Rebellion and the Maine Boundary Dispute.
As Bermuda would be a central factor in any conflict between the USA and Britain, the authorities in Washington sent at least three spies (that we know of!) to Bermuda.
The first was Secret Agent Albert Fitz in late 1841, followed by Captain Minor Knowlton in 1842 and 1849 and Lieutenant Frederick Prime in 1852.
Capt. Knowlton found the Bermuda population of 10,000 to be “universally loyal”.
In his view, “the blacks strongly prefer the English government to our own, and for reasons too obvious to mention. The whites because of the great artificial importance given to the colony by the government and the great expenditures of money made in it in the attempt to make it the great military and naval depot for this part of the world.”
Lieut. Prime was so excited by his visit that he drafted an invasion plan for Bermuda from his later outpost of Fort Alcatraz in California.
New information has come to hand on one of these clandestine visitors from marine artist John Hutchinson, a great-great-grandson of Albert Fitz (www.hutchinsonsart.com).
The illustrations given here are with his courtesy. From a passport issued by Governor Reid on January 29, 1842, we can surmise that Fitz had completed his survey of the Bermuda fortifications and was on his way to the “Turks Islands” on the schor Elizabeth & Esther<$>, possibly the names of two important ladies of the Master, Samuel Nelmes, but his real destination was Nassau, where he checked out Forts Montagu, Charlotte and Fincastle.
By May 1842, he was at Barbados, following an examination of military works at Jamaica, and found it to be the premier British base ihe West Indies.
It is to be hoped, after all the hard work of his team, that Mr. Gregory Slayton, the present US Consul General at Bermuda, has noted an improvement in our attitude.
On the other hand, one wonders what he was doing the other week, lurking about the greatest fortifications at Bermuda at the Dockyard, under the pretext of organisia party for Bermudians.
* * *
Dr. Edward Harris, MBE, JP, FSA, Bermudian, is the Executive Director of the Bermuda Maritime Museum. Cents can be t to drharris@logic.bm or by telephone to 799-5480.