Log In

Reset Password
BERMUDA | RSS PODCAST

Bogus sick leave is reason for bus cancellations, says Lister

Transport Minister Terry Lister has vowed to crack down on bus drivers' sick leave.

Transport Minister Terry Lister has vowed to crack down on bogus sick leave as he says bus drivers are to blame for timetable cuts.Mr Lister has pointed the finger at the “unnecessary number” of bus drivers pulling ‘sickies’ as he struggles to run the timetable with reduced funds.He says drivers “who abuse the system” are disrupting services as transport bosses can no longer afford to pay the overtime costs of replacement drivers.It is estimated that up to ten out of about 130 drivers phone in sick on a daily basis leaving “huge holes” in scheduled services.But Mr Lister is now warning those drivers who phone in sick when they want a day-off that they are “being watched.”He says the Department of Transport is currently “analysing the information” and managers will take the appropriate action to try to prevent further cancellations.Mr Lister said: “These drivers are in the service business and I expect them to provide a service.“But every single day we are experiencing an interruption to services. Some days we have two pages of cancellations to services, this shows how many drivers are off sick, it’s not good enough.“The people of Bermuda deserve better. They are paying for a service with their taxes and they expect it to be delivered.”The Royal Gazette has published several stories on the disruption to bus services after the Department of Transport had its budget reduced by $1.3 million, down seven percent from last year.Bosses have described the cancellations as “cost-effective cuts” but passengers have complained they have been left not knowing when the next bus is going to show up.Mr Lister explained that four drivers, who are not assigned to any routes, are on standby each day to cover routes when drivers call in sick.In the past if more than four drivers called in sick on any given day, off-duty drivers would be called in for overtime at time-and-a-half or double pay.But from April 1, transport bosses changed the set-up so “no drivers means no services.” Mr Lister said they were trying to save money by not “paying two people to do the same job” the driver who called in sick and the replacement driver.So now if more than four drivers call in sick, bosses draw up a cancellation list detailing the route numbers and times of buses that won’t operate.These cancellation lists are being drawn up on an almost daily basis and can contain as many as 25 routes, suggesting that five to 10 drivers are phoning in sick each day.Mr Lister said: “These unassigned drivers don’t know what route they are doing each day. When the first driver calls in sick, the first unassigned driver is sent out and so on and so forth.“This continues until all four drivers are out on the road covering sickness, then we draw up the cancellation list.“We can’t afford to be paying two people to do the same job. If drivers came to work, we wouldn’t have a cancellation list.”Mr Lister said “in an ideal world” he would like to see a 100 percent attendance rate for all bus drivers. This would mean the four unassigned drivers could be “put to good use” elsewhere in the Department of Public Transportation.He said: “I’m not talking about the long-term sick; those people who have a doctor’s note saying they can’t work for however many weeks are taken off the schedule.“And if people genuinely have a cold or the flu, then of course they shouldn’t come in to work and make a whole bus full of people sick.“The real concern is those who phone in sick because they want some time at home or because they are having a bad day. They don’t have a doctor’s note, it’s uncertified leave.“I believe if you are paid to work, you should work, it’s as simple as that.”Mr Lister said the problem of unauthorised sick leave would be addressed. He said PTB bosses were currently analysing the sick day data and would speak to those drivers concerned. Mr Lister said: “We will handle things.”Cancellation lists have been e-mailed to “a select few” since the beginning of the month, but from Wednesday the lists have been sent to the media and put on Facebook. This is to “get the word out to a wider audience.”Mr Lister said cancellation lists were drawn up and circulated at about 11am. He said routes affected tended to be those “used the least” from about midday to 4pm with school children and those needing to get home from work taking priority.Mr Lister stressed that most bus routes ran every 15 or 30 minutes so passengers “wouldn’t have to wait long.”He said: “We believe everyone should be able to get home on the bus, but some may not be able to get home as quickly as they’d like.“Some routes are being cancelled and people will have to wait for the next bus and that will slow them up.”Mr Lister added he found it “bothersome” that bus cancellations were still a talking point, because he was doing his best “to calm the situation down.”He said with “such a significant budget cut” timetable cuts were the only way to save the bus service.Mr Lister said: “We have to run the best service we can provide under the circumstances or I will have to stop providing the service altogether.”Mr Lister added that a normal holiday bus service would run tomorrow (Good Friday) with drivers “being paid as per their contract of service.”

Three family members deny drug charges
Bus drivers are scapegoats: Swan

Bus drivers are being made the scapegoats as services are cut due to poor financial management.

This is the view of UBP leader Kim Swan, acting Shadow Minister for Transport, who says: “The budget figures speak for themselves”.

Mr Swan has hit out at the Ministry of Transport for its “drastic slashing of scheduled bus services.”

He contacted The Royal Gazette after we announced that transport bosses were drawing up a list of up to 25 last-minute bus cancellations on an almost daily basis.

Mr Swan reviewed the Ministry's budget allocation for the 2011/12 financial year and said: “The numbers don't lie and the findings are startling.”

Transport Minister Terry Lister has repeatedly blamed cancellation lists on bus drivers who phone in sick, but Mr Swan insists Government need to better manage their finances.

Mr Swan highlighted that the Department of Public Transportation's administration/management had received a 56 per cent increase in their budget. This represents $700,000 more than what they required to operate the previous year in 2010/11.

Budget figures show that to achieve this, management slashed bus operations' budget allocation by $467,000, stores/spare parts by $848,000, and repair servicing by $521,000, thus cutting maintenance budget by more than $1.6 million.

Mr Swan, who will be addressing the matter in a parliamentary question, said: “It is apparent, looking at the budget book that these cuts, which directly affect safe and reliable provision of services, have been made to accommodate the excessive $700,000 (56 percent) increase in management's administration budget allocation.

“Government should be aiming to provide safe, reliable and comfortable public transportation for people of Bermuda and visitors as has been the case for decades.

“Unfortunately, this latest debacle is yet another example of a Government that lost sight of serving the people.”

However, Mr Lister said he couldn't comment on the previous year's allocations because he was not Minister of Transport then. He admitted the figures didn't seem to add up, saying: “I wouldn't put my head on a chopping board and back those figures.”

Mr Lister said “cuts were crucial” as the Department of Transport had its budget reduced by $1.3 million, down seven percent from last year.

He said the biggest predicted cuts would be in management and drivers' salaries (due to the overtime ban), bus energy costs and general maintenance.

Mr Swan said the output measures in the budget book showed the department had not been able to achieve its goal of a maximum of 15 buses out of service. The actual for the current year was 18.

But Mr Lister said he was not aware of any aims or limits of buses off-road “during his time.”

He said: “We can run the service with 40 buses off the road, but haven't gone beyond 30 off the road in quite some time.

“We have enough buses to do the school runs and the sightseeing tours. Sometimes they are off the road for one day, one week or one month, but the turnover is quite quick.

“This is a nagging comment that we have too many buses out of service but it's just not true.”

Mr Swan also noted that in 2004/05 Public Transportation employed 230 full-time staff, and in 2011/12 they have 255 full-time staff.

Also in 2004/05 there was a budget allocation for charters and sightseeing, but these figures were no longer separately accounted.

Mr Swan added: “Buses are a social requirement throughout a country, they cannot justify cutting services. It's totally unacceptable.”