Landlords, be aware of rent control pitfalls
Landlords considering the purchase or letting of investment accommodation should, as part of their due diligence process, consider if the property is rent-controlled.
Numerous Bermuda properties have been subject to rent control for many years. Currently, residential accommodation with an annual rental value of $22,800, or less, falls under rent control.
The main exceptions to rent control are:
• Accommodation with an ARV over $22,800.
• Employer-owned accommodation, provided under an employment contract.
• Licensed tourist accommodation.
• Accommodation normally occupied by a landlord, who is away from Bermuda, for less than 12 months.
• Boarding or lodging house accommodation.
• If the tenant is what is known as a “life tenant”.
Over time, with ARV revaluations and changing rent control thresholds, accommodation can easily fall into and out of rent control. Prior to January 1, 2016, the ARV threshold for rent control was set at $27,000 or less. On that date, the ARV threshold for rent control was lowered to the current level of $22,800. Consequently, additional accommodation escaped rent control from that day forward.
In particular, beware rent set by a previous landlord in breach of rent control. A past breach, even without the knowledge of a current landlord, may subject a current landlord to financial liabilities.
Rent control legislation not only restricts rent, but also provides security of tenure to rent-controlled tenants. This means a court order is required to evict a rent-controlled tenant; but take care as other kinds of tenant also require a court order, before eviction.
Additionally a deposit paid by a tenant, with respect to rent-controlled accommodation, should not exceed the higher of $100, or the equivalent of two weeks’ rent.
Contact the Rent Commissioner’s office by telephone or e-mail, to ask if accommodation is, or has ever been rent-controlled. The Rent Commissioner’s website, with forms and FAQs can be found at www.gov.bm/rent-increase-information-tenants-and-landlords.
Even if otherwise falling under rent control, accommodation not previously let (eg a newly constructed unit), may first be rented at any level of rent. However, any subsequent rent increase, whether to the same or to a different tenant, is restricted.
Rent should not be higher than the rent charged to the first tenant of a rent-controlled property (even if by a previous landlord) unless:
• The landlord and tenant have agreed an increase, following which (a) the landlord has lodged notice with the Rent Commissioner; and (b) the landlord is in possession of a copy of such notice, duly endorsed by the Rent Commissioner.
• Or the landlord has received the Rent Commissioner’s determination, approving an increase.
If a landlord applies to the Rent Commissioner for an increase, the Rent Commissioner firstly consults with the tenant. If there is no tenant, no such consultation is required. The Rent Commissioner then determines the rent.
If a landlord or a tenant is dissatisfied with a Rent Commissioner determination, either may apply for a review. The Rent Commissioner then consults the Rent Increases Advisory Panel, before final determination. After a final determination, there is a right of appeal to the Magistrates’ Court.
A prospective tenant cannot agree a rent increase to a rent-controlled property. Instead, a landlord should lodge an application for increase, with the Rent Commissioner.
Contravention of rent control can result in criminal prosecution and/or a tenant claim against the landlord, for up to two years of rent paid in excess of controlled rent (even if paid to a previous landlord of the accommodation in question). Additionally, a seller of rent-controlled property, may have to make concessions to a purchaser, if a purchaser cannot be satisfied rent control has been observed.
In summary, the status of investment accommodation should be investigated and once known and if appropriate, steps can be considered to correct, or mitigate potential disadvantage.
Neil Molyneux is a member of the Corporate and Property Teams at Appleby. A copy of this column is available on the firm’s web site at www.applebyglobal.com
This column should not be used as a substitute for professional legal advice. Before proceeding with any matters discussed here, persons are advised to consult with a lawyer
Gay couple appeal for dignity
New online clothes store launched
Wilkerson: Bill a step back for human rights
Teacher extradited on sexual assault charges
Kenny Harris (1927-2017)
Move to tackle drug culture as well as laws
Praise for island’s efforts to tackle racism
Passenger died on plane of natural causes
Take Our Poll