Log In

Reset Password

Street poll gets mixed response to expat ID plan

Delmos Campbell

The Royal Gazette hit the streets of Hamilton yesterday to find out what Bermudians and expatriates alike thought about Government's announcement to issue guest workers ID cards.

Renneka Hill, a 27-year old client administrator said: "I think it's a good idea because it is in line with other countries.

"I know France has them. It's on par with the rest of the world".

Lawyer Cynthia Millet agreed saying: "I agree as other jurisdictions provide ID for expatriate workers.

"Having assisted clients in applying for work permits, the actual work permit Immigration provides is a sheet of paper which is neither compact or durable, especially if you travel often. It should be the same form of ID like a driver's license."

However, Kurt Madeiros disagreed with idea and said: "I think that they're going a bit far.

"They are overdoing the emphasis on expats. They're driving more of a wedge between Bermudians and expats and it's not needed."

The 30-year old maintenance man also said: "An ID card is probably good on one side but there's got to be something better.

"Making them have ID cards is like saying 'hey, you're different, get off our Island'."

Mr. Madeiros also said the Department of Immigration should keep all the information on file so when guest workers return to the Island, once their passport is scanned, their work permit information should immediately come up as well.

Liz O'Mahony, a software developer said having an ID card would probably make life as a guest worker easier.

"I think if they use it instead of paper, it's a lot smarter. I don't think it's disrespectful. She continued: "Coming through immigration and having to use the work permit, it would be easier to have the card"

Ms O'Mahony said she wouldn't be offended if issued the card and explained she had worked in many other countries where there were similar ID cards.

Teacher Delmos Campbell said he didn't have a problem with the concept but said he isn't sure if it will work to stamp out illegal residents.

The 47-year old said: "It's easier to carry. I don't walk with my work permit. I'm not sure if it will solve the problem in the long run with those who are here illegally."

Richard Paynter, an architect, said: "In some respects, it protects people's professional qualifications and expertise in fields.

"It ensures they have the appropriate qualifications and skills to do the job. It depends on how it's used".

The 40-year old also said it makes sense from a consumer point of view and added: "I think there are other things I find more irritating that carrying a card".

Renneka Hill
Cynthia Millett
Liz O'Mahony
Kurt Madeiros
Richard Paynter